Makhana vs Pumpkin Seeds: Which Is the Better Healthy Snack?
Share
Quick answer: Pumpkin seeds have about three times the protein of makhana and far more magnesium, zinc and iron. Makhana is much lower in fat and calories per handful. Choose pumpkin seeds for protein and minerals, and makhana for a light, low-fat crunch. Many people eat both.
Makhana vs pumpkin seeds per 100g
| Per 100g (approx.) | Makhana (fox nuts) | Pumpkin seeds |
|---|---|---|
| Protein | 9-10g | 30g |
| Energy | ~350 kcal | ~560 kcal |
| Fat | under 1g | ~49g (mostly unsaturated) |
| Carbohydrates | ~77g | ~11g |
| Magnesium | moderate | 550-590mg |
| Zinc | low | ~7.8mg |
Approximate values from published nutrition data (USDA FoodData Central for pumpkin seeds; Indian food composition data for makhana). Values vary by variety and processing.
Which is better for protein?
Pumpkin seeds, clearly. A 30g handful gives about 8-9g of protein, compared with about 3g from the same weight of makhana. If you are vegetarian and trying to add protein to snacks, pumpkin seeds are one of the best options. See pumpkin seeds protein per 100g.
Which is lighter?
Makhana. It is almost fat-free and very airy, so a big bowl weighs little. Pumpkin seeds are calorie-dense, so stick to about 30g at a time.
Which is better for evening cravings?
Both work as a swap for fried namkeen, as long as they are roasted, not fried. Many flavoured makhana and seed snacks in the market are cooked in oil, so check the label. Ours are dry-roasted with no frying oil.
The smart answer: rotate them
- Pumpkin seeds after the gym or as a mid-day protein snack
- Makhana with evening chai when you want volume and crunch
- Mix both into a homemade trail mix
Try our oil-free flavoured pumpkin seeds in Peri Peri, Lime N Chilli, Creamy Cheese and Himalayan Pink Salt. Retailers and corporates can also enquire about oil-free flavoured makhana in bulk.
